Video Performance

Along the same lines as still image performance, video performance is evaluated by using relative comparisons with various smartphones. However, unlike still image testing we attempt to more strongly emphasize the need for effective image stabilization, whether through digital or optical means. As we lack a standardized testing rig for various types of motion, these tests are purely relative and should only be used to compare between two different devices that are recording at the same time.

There are also a number of factors that affect image quality here, as there is both a need to meet real time latency targets and keep spatial resolution as high as possible. As a result, there is a stronger emphasis on ISP performance as digital image stabilization, sensor correction, lens correction, demosaicing, and other compute tasks must be done at rates as high as 480 FPS depending upon the device, with resolutions reaching as high as 2160p for output.

Looking at the stats for 1080p30 video, we see that the LG G4 uses 17Mbps high profile H.264 and 96Kbps AAC at 48KHz stereo audio, which is pretty much par for the course for high-end smartphones as far as I can tell. Comparing it to the Galaxy S6 shows that contrast is a bit lower, but dynamic range appears to be higher as well. Detail is also pretty much comparable, although the high contrast of the Galaxy S6 seems to help with improving edge contrast in certain scenarios.

The big differences are in audio quality and stabilization, where the G4 appears to reset often and is less able to dampen significant motion while the GS6 manages to avoid resetting the OIS as often and appears to have a greater maximum angle before the OIS reaches a travel limit. The G4 also has sharper wind noise, although the difference isn't enormous there, and in general noises seem to be a bit louder on the G4's video here. The color balance here is also slightly too cold for some reason.

In the interest of trying to add some more comparison points I also added the iPhone 6, which has noticeably more natural stabilization than either the G4 or the GS6. The tighter crop of the iPhone 6 also helps with improving detail, as I suspect all three are pretty much limited by the 1080p resolution rather than encode settings. The G4 also ends up noticeably louder relative to the iPhone 6, which is closer to the GS6 in terms of sound profile.

Unfortunately, there's no 1080p60 sample because for some reason I couldn't find the option to enable it in the G4's camera application, which feels like a pretty significant omission as any sort of movement would benefit greatly from greater temporal resolution. However, LG does have 4K30 recording, which has the same settings as 1080p30 but with a 30Mbps bit rate for video. Once again, the Galaxy S6 and G4 are incredibly close here in terms of detail, but the G4 avoids excessively high contrast and seems to expose to allow for much more shadow detail. OIS continues to reset more often, and noise tends to not be suppressed as well as it is on the Galaxy S6.

Moving on to slow motion, the G4 supports a maximum of 720p120 played back at 30 FPS, with 24Mbps baseline H.264, with identical audio to the other two video modes. Comparing this mode to the Galaxy S6, it's clear that the Galaxy S6 has much better detail and less obvious pixelation/blockiness throughout the video. As a result, it's also not as good as the iPhone 6 at slow motion video at 720p120. Neither the Galaxy S6 nor the G4 support 720p240, so the iPhone 6 definitely stands alone there as well.

Overall, video quality is acceptable, but slightly trails the Galaxy S6 due to slightly worse noise cancellation, worse slow motion video capture, and the lack of 1080p60 video mode. The slightly more obvious OIS might also be a negative, but this is somewhat subjective as it's basically up to the end user to decide whether they want to see large resets of the OIS somewhat rarely or smaller resets that happen more often. I personally would rather see simple dampening of motion rather than completely compensating for it, as in cases where it's almost impossible to completely defeat the motion with OIS video will appear unnatural and strange, to say the least. If the G4 has a downfall in camera, it's in video quality.

Still Image Performance Snapdragon 808 & System Performance
Comments Locked


View All Comments

  • Fitnesspro - Thursday, July 30, 2015 - link

    Will keep my NEXUS 5 for now. Still under warranty. Will see the nee NEXUS 5, 2015, then decide
  • ThisIsChrisKim - Thursday, July 30, 2015 - link

    Yeah, the touch response isn't as great as I'd like--but it's not horrid (nothing like the OnePlus One). I miss maybe one touch a day.

    The framerate does jank once in a while (usually on websites in Chrome that have horrible overlay ads). I'm thinking about root to install Adaway but am reluctant for losing the 1-year warranty...

    And yeah, the Nexus software experience is definitely superior. But I was done giving up good camera and battery swapping for the software. I'd rather have those two things in the end at the expense of software.

    The great thing is, we have so many choices at competitive prices these days! It's really a blessing.
  • Pissedoffyouth - Friday, July 31, 2015 - link

    Can't you unroot it and then you have warrenty? Or do they have knox like system?
  • jvl - Thursday, July 30, 2015 - link

    I thought the Nexus 5 2015 will use a 820? Is that benchmark-leak-rumor where it crushed all outdated?
  • grayson_carr - Thursday, July 30, 2015 - link

    Some people now think that benchmark is from another LG flagship that is expected to launch this fall.
  • ThisIsChrisKim - Thursday, July 30, 2015 - link

    SD820 seems unlikely to launch in the fall.
  • toyotabedzrock - Thursday, July 30, 2015 - link

    Looking at the performance Google would be disappointed with sales if the Nexus 5 2015 uses the 808.
  • tipoo - Thursday, July 30, 2015 - link

    I like the style of pictures in this and the Apple Watch review Josh!
  • Pissedoffyouth - Thursday, July 30, 2015 - link

    Cheers Josh.

    Looks like this may be my next phone considering no other major phones have a removable battery I can swap with Zerolemon one
  • Drumsticks - Thursday, July 30, 2015 - link

    Thanks for the review! Did Motorola leave you with review units after the press event, so that you're able to start reviewing it now?

    I'll be passing my S6 to my mom likely, and picking up a new phone. Ive had the battery life be way to inconsistent for me (everything from 3-5 hours of screen on time with the same uses). I'll probably get the G4, OP 2, or Moto X. Anandtech reviews make deciding much better :D

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now