Final Thoughts

It's difficult to summarize our experiences with the Edge Z55. We were certainly plagued with a number of issues, but our impression coming away is that this is the result of the early adoption of the X58 platform and Core i7, and the growing pains that come with it. In terms of fit and finish, Velocity Micro does a great job of differentiating their product from the pack with visual appeal, clean assembly, and the largest number of BIOS, program, and operating system tweaks that we've ever seen in a PC supplier. In the line item of "performance tuning", Velocity Micro promises small and delivers big. Every component choice was top quality, and their support high caliber. They do, in fact, still have what it takes to compete with the boutiques. It's difficult to put a gut feeling into words, but this felt like it was a solid offering that just kept missing the mark.

On the other hand, if we put ourselves in the seat of a consumer who had purchased this system, we would be sorely disappointed. The problems that we encountered were frustrating enough just in benchmarking; if this was an anticipated gaming machine for home use, the user would most assuredly have become disgusted regardless of the steps taken to correct it. There are also some areas we feel they fall short, such as not offering guaranteed overclocks (like their associated Overdrive PC branch) and retaining a standard Intel heatsink and fan, often as their sole offering.

When it comes to systems, different users are looking for different things. In the arena of top-notch gaming machines that set themselves apart from the crowd (and those willing to pay for it), we would have awarded Velocity Micro an Editor's Choice award if the system had followed through. As it is, we can't do that today, but came away with a good impression of Velocity Micro despite the bad taste in our mouth from the problems we had. We'd still recommend keeping them on your short list of high-end suppliers, and welcome them to submit another (more mature) product for consideration in the future. Being first out the gate with new hardware is great… but only if the hardware actually works as advertised.

Overclocking
Comments Locked

27 Comments

View All Comments

  • Matt Campbell - Friday, December 12, 2008 - link

    Thanks for the input. One of the main reasons we include the Reseller Ratings numbers, and read through and comment on the feedback there, is to convey across a broad number of people (and not just our one experience) what the customer service impression is. This time around, we also provided information on our experience with Mario, who was our system builder and therefore (at VM) the tech. support rep.
  • UNHchabo - Friday, December 12, 2008 - link

    This was a pre-production system, so it'd be obvious that a reviewer was calling. ;)
  • Harby - Friday, December 12, 2008 - link

    Is there a reason that Intel mobo was used? I mean, its probaly the worst X58 mobo atm, mainly because it only incorporates 4 DIMM slots.
  • Matt Campbell - Friday, December 12, 2008 - link

    Likely because VM is an Intel Premier Partner :)

    Also, being a first launch system, the Intel boards are often the farthest along in development and stability at launch date.
  • privater - Friday, December 12, 2008 - link

    weeks ago,heard form other article that the dimm voltage must below 1.65v .but this rig seems use 1.90v ?
  • Matt Campbell - Friday, December 12, 2008 - link

    There is a warning present in the BIOS about exceeding 1.65V, and Intel is requiring some vendors to put warning labels on their motherboard packaging. 1.9V was the setting that Velocity Micro provided on the system, and we tested it as such, but reducing it to stock did not solve the stability problems on the first system.

    In Gary's X58 article, he pushed the MSI board up to a 1.90V VDIMM as well.
  • privater - Friday, December 12, 2008 - link

    weeks ago,heard form other article that the dimm voltage must below 1.65v .but this rig seems use 1.90v ?

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now